Option one: standard architectural shingles
This is the roof most homes in the area wear today. It is a layered asphalt shingle that looks good, goes on quickly and comes in a wide range of colours. It sheds water and handles ordinary wind well when it is installed with the right nail pattern and good underlayment.
What it does not do is shrug off a serious hailstorm. Collin County sits in a part of Texas where hail is part of the spring. A standard shingle can be bruised by a hard strike, and the damage is often invisible from the street until granules start washing into the gutters. If you plan to move within a few years and your policy covers hail in full, this option is a reasonable, sensible one. It is also the easiest to repair in sections, and matching a standard colour is rarely a problem.
Option two: impact-rated shingles
Impact-rated shingles use a tougher, more flexible mat so they resist cracking when something heavy lands on them. They are tested against a falling steel ball, and the rating is written on the packaging. They look much like a normal shingle, so you give up very little on appearance.
The cost is a higher material and labour line, and the benefit depends on your policy. Some insurers offer a discount for a rated roof, and some do not, so call your agent and ask in writing before you decide. If you plan to stay a decade or more, or you have had hail claims on the street before, this is the one I would look at first. Make sure the crew is trained to install it, because a tougher shingle does not forgive sloppy nailing.
Option three: a standing seam or ribbed metal roof
Metal is the long-term choice. It handles hail dents better than most owners expect, sheds water and heat well, and can last through several shingle cycles. It also behaves differently in the Texas sun, expanding and contracting through the day, so the fastening method matters a great deal.
The trade-offs are the upfront cost, the sound of a heavy rain on a bare panel unless the attic is well insulated, and the fact that a dent can still be cosmetic damage. Check your homeowners association rules before you fall in love with a profile, since some neighbourhoods in Plano and Frisco limit panel styles and colours.
Questions that settle it
First, how long will you stay? Under five years leans toward standard. Ten years or more leans toward impact-rated or metal. Second, what does your insurer say about hail and about rated roofs? Get the answer in writing. Third, how much tree cover do you have? Limbs rub, drop and scrape, and a tougher roof helps there too.
Fourth, what does the attic look like? A roof is only as good as the ventilation and decking under it, so a stiffer shingle on soft decking is money badly spent.
Finally, ask each contractor to show you the manufacturer's installation instructions for the product they quote. A good installation of a modest shingle beats a careless installation of an expensive one every time. We work across Plano, Frisco, Allen, McKinney, Richardson, Murphy and Wylie, and whichever roof you pick, the decision should be made on paper, not under pressure after a storm.
